iai plus banner


Philosophy for our times: cutting edge debates and talks from the world's leading thinkers

Music's Mystery:

The secret to music's emotion

to get free unlimited access to all videos on iai tv and all articles on iai news, as well as advance notice of the events.
You can watch up to an hour of video per month and 20 mins of any one video without signing up.
You have watched half an hour of our debates and talks on iai tv. To watch more than an hour of video per month or more than 20 mins of any one video you need to join iai+. Joining iai+ is free and gives you free unlimited access to iai tv and iai news.
You have watched your maximum monthly limit of videos. Join iai+ to view an unlimited number of videos on iai tv and articles on iai news. Joining iai+ is free and only takes a minute.

Joanna Bailie, Philip Ball, Michael McIntyre. Gabrielle Walker hosts.

Since the Pythagoreans first investigated the relationship between mathematics and harmony, we have developed theories to explain away the power of music. Is this an error? Should we relish the ineffability of music, or is this a capitulation to mindless romanticism?

The Panel

Composer Joanna Bailie, Cambridge systems physicist Michael McIntyre, and author of The Music Instinct Philip Ball ask whether it is possible to explain music's power.

In association with the SHM Foundation

MC Xander
MC Xander
United Vibrations
United Vibrations
Trust Me, I'm Google
Ben Hammersley, Matt Jameson Evans, Victoria Lambert, Mark Salter
Jump to what you want to see in the debate
  • Joanna Bailie
    The Pitch
    No single theory can explain the power of music
  • Michael McIntyre
    The Pitch
    We may analyse it, but we will never solve music's mystery
  • Philip Ball
    The Pitch
    We still don't know what makes for great music
  • The Debate
    Theme One
    How does music incite our emotions?
  • The Debate
    Theme Two
    Cultural illusions
  • The Debate
    Theme Three
    Mathematics and music
Join the conversation

to post comments or join now (only takes a moment). Don't have an account? Sign in with Facebook, Twitter or Google to get started:

rosinhaly on 08/11/2013 2:21pm

The emotional response we get to music is something very human in my mind. It seems difficult to believe that it's to do with McIntyre pleasant platonic objects or Ball's mislead expectations... Music does move us in a way that simple speech doesn't though, and perhaps Mark Changizi was right, when he suggested that music moves us because it's been culturally selected to sound like an emotionally expressive human.

Henry on 08/11/2013 12:32pm

I think it requires quite a leap of faith to take as a given that the reason why music incites emotion in us is due to the setting up of expectations which are then broken. There is almost nothing there to suggest that this is why music affects us, the fact that it does however is beyond question. Advances in neuroscience, most famously the creation and refinement of brain imaging, has shown that both listening to and creating music creates changes in our brain chemistry. Surely you cannot trick yourself by creating an expectation and then breaking it? Isn't that by itself already enough to undermine this theory?

Copy and paste the code below to embed or link to this video.

Embed options
  • Video Seek
    Converted to a link which jumps to that point in the video
    Example: 00:34
  • Bold Text
    Example: [b]Bold[/b]
  • Italic Text
    Example: [i]Italics[/i]
  • Underlined Text
    Example: [u]Underlined[/u]
  • Website link
    Link to another website or URL
    Example: [url]http://www.website.com/[/url]

Rate this talk with three clicks. You can choose 3 words, or vote for the same word 3 times.

Why register with the iai?
  • All you can watch
    Unlimited access to hundreds of hours of debates and talks from the world's leading minds, all for free.
  • Have your say
    Join the iai community and engage in conversation and debate around the issues that matter.
  • Hear it first
    Be the first to hear about our video releases, articles and tickets to our festival HowTheLightGetsIn.