Beyond Good and Evil

Can animals – and even machines – be moral?

At stake in this issue of IAI News is the very possibility of good and evil. Do these concepts really exist? And, if so, are they unique to humans? Or can animals – and even machines – be moral too?

Last issue saw philosopher Stephen Law and Anglican theologist John Milbank engage in heated debate about the role of philosophy in the battle between science and religion. This issue sees their Head to Head develop and intensify. At root now is the very possibility of good and of evil. Law argues that Milbank’s defence of religion amounts to little more than pseudo-profundity. Milbank hits back: when comparing the finite and the infinite, he says, paradox is a powerful tool.

Two further contributors extend the debate on good and evil to the non-human world. At issue for both biologist Colin Tudge and philosopher Mark Rowlands is the question of responsibility. Tudge argues that certain more intelligent animals are indeed responsible for their actions (although this should not change how we treat them). Rowlands disagrees. He argues that morality must be decoupled from the concept responsibility. That way, we can understand that animals are capable of moral actions.

Lastly, Artificial Intelligence expert Nigel Shadbolt ponders the future of non-human intelligence. Our technologies may be more powerful than ever, he says, but is human stupidity the real threat to our future?

Continue reading

Enjoy unlimited access to the world's leading thinkers.

Start by exploring our subscription options or joining our mailing list today.

Start Free Trial

Already a subscriber? Log in

Latest Releases
Join the conversation

Emily Elyard 29 February 2020

site [url=https://ww.google.com/]thanks[/url]

smith sera 19 February 2020

Beyond sensible & evil is an action-escapade computer game advanced and printed by Ubisoft for the PlayStation 2, PC, Xbox and GameCube display place. The level follows the journeys of Olive, a fact-finding newsman and martial creator, who works with a fight program to reveal an earth-wide alien intrigue. According to the stresses of <a href="https://www.britishessaywriting.co.uk">best essay writing service</a>, everywhere it is imperative for every person when you surprise to thorough your effort.

Philip Mitchell 25 January 2020

Beyond good and evil, You have to complete your work. I have some prefrences here which telling you to come and make your work according to the demands of [url=https://www.nerdywriters.co.uk/]genuine essay writing service uk[/url], Where it is important for everyone when you start to complete your work.