Einstein vs Bohr: Quantum reality is still up for grabs

The conflict at the heart of physics

For decades, the story went that Bohr’s anti-realism triumphed over Einstein’s quest for a deeper reality. Physicists were told to "shut up and calculate" and metaphysical debates were dismissed as distractions. But today, realist interpretations of quantum mechanics constantly emerge and the anti-realist position is far from the mainstream – so if Bohr won, why does almost no one take his side? University of Massachusetts Boston physicist Jacques Pienaar argues that we’ve been wrong all along – Bohr was not an anti-realist after all, and Einstein's apparent realism is not on sure-footing.

 

One grey morning in Vienna in 2014, I paused on the steps of the historic Strudlhofstiege. Its emblem, a fish-head that spouted water into an algae-stained basin, stared back at me with melancholy century-old eyes. I passed this spot every day on my way to work at the quantum physics institute of the University of Vienna, and found that gazing at the fountain and listening to the gentle splashing of water often helped me work through difficult physics problems. Today, a veil of fine rain dampened my face as I wondered: just what was the Copenhagen interpretation?

___

According to the usual telling of the story, Einstein's case for ‘realism’ lost, and the ‘anti-realist’ Copenhagen interpretation, championed mainly by Bohr and Heisenberg, emerged victorious.

___

As an undergraduate, I was enthralled by the atmosphere of drama and mystery surrounding the famous debates between Bohr and Einstein, which for me was perfectly captured by the iconic grainy photo of the two great scientists reclining side by side, Bohr laughing as Einstein shares some joke whose punchline we will never hear, his hand raised in an enigmatic gesture. For a long time, I was sure he was holding a cigar, until one day I examined the photo carefully and found his fingers empty.

 Einstein and Bohr Getting along

According to the folklore, during their intense but convivial discussions in public and in private, Einstein argued that quantum mechanics had to be an incomplete description of reality, while Bohr argued that he was missing the point: quantum theory was never meant to describe reality, only predict what could be observed in experiments and communicated in terms we could understand, a function for which the theory was entirely sufficient. According to the usual telling of the story, Einstein's case for ‘realism’ lost, and the ‘anti-realist’ Copenhagen interpretation, championed mainly by Bohr and Heisenberg, emerged victorious.

related-video-image SUGGESTED VIEWING Quantum and the unknowable universe With Slavoj Žižek, Roger Penrose, Sabine Hossenfelder, Güneş Taylor

Like all good stories, it has a few grains of truth. During the war years and long afterwards, young physicists were frequently discouraged by their advisors from working on ‘metaphysical’ questions, on the grounds that Bohr had cleared up the confusion and there was nothing more to be said[1]. Quantum theory was a tool for calculating probabilities for observable events, and inquiring into the metaphysical causes of such events was a dead end. Fortunately, not all took this advice to heart. Looking back on the situation, physicist David Mermin said, “If I were forced to sum up in one sentence what the Copenhagen interpretation says to me, it would be “Shut up and calculate!”[2]. Einstein's own assessment was even more scathing: “The Heisenberg-Bohr tranquilizing philosophy – or religion? – is so delicately contrived that, for the time being, it provides a gentle pillow for the true believer from which he cannot very easily be aroused. So let him lie there.”[3]

Continue reading

Enjoy unlimited access to the world's leading thinkers.

Start by exploring our subscription options or joining our mailing list today.

Start Free Trial

Already a subscriber? Log in

Latest Releases
Join the conversation

Hogan Denman 11 April 2025

SHI Professional Funds Recovery in the U.S. is a beacon of hope for those affected by online scams. As a victim of a romance scam that resulted in significant financial loss, I was devastated. But SHI's expert team helped me recover my funds and regain control of my digital life.

Whether you're a coin trader who's lost access to your account or a victim of online scams, SHI is here to help. Their services extend to resolving security issues and recovering access to social media accounts.

visit. shi- us .com to get started and take the first step towards recovering your lost funds. SHI's professionalism and expertise are unmatched – don't hesitate to reach out for help!

tilmann wendland 9 April 2025

I Thought It Was All Gone! One minute, I struggled through the rush-hour chaos at Grand Central; the next, my phone was gone. A sly pickpocket had stolen it right out of my coat pocket. The panic set in immediately. That phone was my portal to everything, including access to my $315,000 Bitcoin fortune, set aside for my children's education. With my device lost, my two-factor authentication codes were out of reach, and the exchange did not have a backup recovery option. My mind raced: my children losing college educations, my careful financial planning ruined by seconds of distraction.
I stumbled over onto a bench, cradling my briefcase in life-preserver mode. Catching my breath through tears, I was suddenly hit with sympathy from a strange, kind old gentleman whose newspaper sported a circle of coffee spots—and who gave me a rough but hopeful-scribbled brochure. "Tech Cyber Force Recovery pulled my brother from a terror such as you just experienced. Call them up, son." Desperation got the better of doubt. I called in the afternoon. Their crew took to me immediately from the beginning. They sat and listened to the entire thing, every detail of how crowded the station had been to how fearful I was for my children's future. They assured me that all of this could be fixed. Their peaceful belief lifted me like a life preserver that floated me along.
The process of recovery was as meticulous as open-heart surgery. They spoke directly to my exchange provider, coordinating time zones and levels of security. I received daily updates, always in plain human language. Even when nothing had yet changed, they would send me reassuring messages to inform me they were still fighting for me. After eight long days, the call came. My wallet was restored. Tech Cyber Force Recovery did more than recover my Bitcoin, they recovered my peace of mind and my family's future.

FOR SERVICES
TELEGRAM AT TECHCYBERFORC

WhatsApp +15617263697