Evolution or revolution

What’s the best way forward on consciousness?

Is the hard problem of consciousness as hard as it seems? Can we rely on science to solve it, or must we look elsewhere for satisfactory answers? Philip Goff repsonds to Peter Vickers' recent IAI News piece. Read Bernardo Kastrup's response here

It’s broadly agreed that consciousness poses a profound challenge to contemporary science: a ‘hard problem’ as David Chalmers famously put it. Some theorists, including myself, think we need to radically rethink our scientific picture of the universe in order to solve it. Others think we should plug away with our standard methods of investigating the brain and gradually chip away at the problem until one day we wake up to find the problem’s no longer there.

Peter Vickers, in an interesting recent piece for IAI, takes a nuanced middle way. We should recognize that the hard problem is a philosophical problem and that as such it should be sharply distinguished from problems that can be tackled with scientific methods. In terms of the latter, we can gather hard evidence that may ultimately command consensus; we are sometimes even able to settle matters and thereby add to the body of knowledge we teach to our undergraduates.

But on the philosophical question of whether materialism, dualism, panpsychism or idealism is true, we have to accept that, whilst there may be reasons that point to one or other view, ‘the reasons are ‘philosophical’ and so of limited persuasive power.’ In the absence of strong evidence supporting one or other of these theories, we ought simply to be agnostic as to which is true.

We are not here talking about the science of consciousness, but about the philosophy of consciousness.

It is of course correct that there’s no consensus among philosophers on the correct theory of consciousness. But there is in fact a point of consensus which Vickers doesn’t bring to our attention. Philosophers of consciousness are almost unanimous in thinking the following view is false:

Temporary Hard Problem – There is a hard problem but our current scientific approach will solve it.

This is very significant, as it seems to me that ‘Temporary Hard Problem’ is a very popular view amongst scientists and science enthusiasts. This mismatch is part of the reason I’m pretty confident there’s a revolution on its way.

99% of philosophers working on the hard problem fit into one of the following three camps:

 

Continue reading

Enjoy unlimited access to the world's leading thinkers.

Start by exploring our subscription options or joining our mailing list today.

Start Free Trial

Already a subscriber? Log in

Latest Releases
Join the conversation

Dorothy Hughes 2 November 2021

This can be the words that sustains me on track straight through my day. I’ve been searching around due to this site after being known as them from the colleague and was thrilled after i could locate it after in search of very long time.

ida sanka 2 September 2021

Awesome blog by the way and thanks for sharing! [url="https://pestcontrolpuebloco.com"]pest control near me[/url]

killer smile 2 September 2021

Thanks a lot for sharing us about this update. Hope you will not get tired on making posts as informative as this.
[url=https://dentalimplantsseattlewa.com]dental implants seattle wa[/url]

Perry Letterman 18 July 2021

You got my attention for this topic. really interesting

Perry | Team [url=https://www.peoria-tree-service.com]tree trimming[/url]

Sam Lap 16 July 2021

Thanks alot for this good post <a href="https://www.electriciensteadele.ca/">.</a>

Jordan Holt 7 June 2021

As humans, we keep on evolving for the betterment of society. https://www.sunshinecoastcarports.com.au

Michelle James 31 May 2021

Nice Topic about the best way forward on consciousness. Well explained. Thanks for the uploader of this content.

Michelle | Tree Pruning
----------------
https://www.florissanttreeservice.com

Michelle James 31 May 2021

Nice Topic about the best way forward on consciousness. Well explained. Thanks for the uploader of this content.

Michelle
----------------
[=https://www.florissanttreeservice.com]Tree Pruning[/url]

Eric Kraft 21 May 2021

Excellent read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was doing some research on that. And he just bought me lunch because I found it for him smile.

Eric,
[url]https://agedcaredecisions.com.au[/url]

bella rose 6 May 2021

I was very encouraged to find this site. The reason being that this is such an informative post. Thanks for sharing!
https://www.sunshinecoastcabinetmakers.com/

bella rose 6 May 2021

Glad to see this post, I like the content of this forum.
<p><a href="https://sunshinecoastcabinetmakers.com/" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">https://sunshinecoastcabinetmakers.com/</a></p>

Dorothy Hughes 4 May 2021

I bookmarked it and will be back to check it out some more later. Great stuff, you helped me out so much!

Dorothy | [url=https://www.loftconversioninsurrey.co.uk]loft fitters[/url]

William Newell 4 May 2021

This post is so right! When I'm stuck with something, I tend to leave it for a while and do something else. Then when I come back to it, some fancy solution always hit me. Very effective. Are you looking for a [url=https://www.endoftenancycleaningincamberley.co.uk]cleaning services[/url] for your house?

Bessie Watts 12 April 2021

Our consciousness is always a part of yourself but for [url="http://vitm.com/"]churches in bucyrus ohio[/url], life is more precious!

Bessie Watts 12 April 2021

Our consciousness is always a part of yourself but for <a href="http://vitm.com/">churches in bucyrus ohio</a>, life is more precious!

Sara Fritz 25 March 2021

The benefactors examine the mind boggling job of the monetary area, the general parts of money related and monetary approach, the restrictions of financial arrangement to address monetary strength, the requirement for monetary strategy to assume a more dynamic part in adjustment, and the overall jobs of monetary guideline and macroprudential devices. The overall message is an admonition against returning to précises ways—to limit swelling focusing on, little utilization of monetary arrangement for adjustment, and lacking monetary guideline.

Sara,
[url]https://www.montgomerycountytree.com/about-contact[/url]

William Roberts 25 March 2021

Thanks for taking this opportunity to discuss this. I feel fervently about this and I like learning about this subject, [url=https://www.emondagelongueuil.com/]read more[/url] here.

Jane Jones 1 24 February 2021

I have to voice my passion for your kindness giving support to those people that should have guidance on this important matter. http://finishedbasementkanata.com/

Jane Jones 1 24 February 2021

I have to voice my passion for your kindness giving support to those people that should have guidance on this important matter. <a href="http://finishedbasementkanata.com/">http://finishedbasementkanata.com/</a>

goalken highlight 19 December 2020

Nice Information thanks for sharing. May you bring this more in future. [URL=https://run3sonline.com/]run 3[/URL]

Martin Helmer 14 December 2020

Smart. I like the suggested vector of attack.