How Would Hume Explain Our Political Divisions?

We are all governed by passions.

“Reason is, and ought only to be, the slave of the passions, and can never pretend to any other office than to serve and obey them,” Scottish philosopher David Hume famously said in his Treatise of Human Nature. He also offered a theory about the way that emotions spread among people, which helps explain the divisiveness of our current politics.

How Actions are Produced

According to Hume, all our intentional actions are the immediate product of passions -- or emotions, feelings, or desires, as we would say today. He does not think that any other kind of mental state could, on its own, bring about an intentional action, except if it first generates a passion. Not all the passions can become motives for action, however. Beyond instincts such as hunger and lust, only desire and aversion, hope and fear, joy and grief, or combinations of these, generate action. How? A feeling of pleasure or pain, whether physical or psychological, or a belief that pleasure or pain may or will come from something, occurs in the mind and causes the passion that brings about action.

Hume famously attacks most moral philosophers, ancient and modern, for claiming that there is conflict between our passions and our reason. He claims to prove that “reason alone can never be a motive to any action of the will,” and that reason, all by itself, “can never oppose passion in the direction of the will.” Hume’s view is not, of course, that reason plays no role in getting us to act; he grants that reason provides information, in particular about means to our ends, which makes a difference to what we do. But reason alone, he thinks, cannot move us to act; the impulse must come from emotion or desire or aversion – from passion. Reason can only pursue and obtain knowledge of logical and mathematical relations and of cause and effect; passion then uses this information to chase its goals effectively.

Hume allows that, speaking imprecisely, we often say that we are being unreasonable in wanting or feeling something because the passion arises in response to a mistaken judgment or opinion.  I want to eat a certain fruit, for example, because I believe it will be delicious, but in fact it’s bitter, and when I discover this, I may carelessly say that my desire for the fruit was unreasonable.  But strictly speaking, even here it’s not the desire but the judgment that’s unreasonable. No passion goes against reason, not even having “a more ardent affection for… my own acknowledg'd lesser good [than] my greater.” It’s imprudent to want what is worse for me, according to Hume, but it’s not against reason.

___

"Reason alone cannot move us to act; the impulse must come from emotion or desire or aversion – from passion"

___

It follows from these views that reason can’t evaluate the goals people set for themselves.  Only our passions can select our goals, and since reason can’t evaluate our passions, it can’t judge our goals to be irrational. All it can do is discover which means to our chosen ends are most likely to be effective.

Continue reading

Enjoy unlimited access to the world's leading thinkers.

Start by exploring our subscription options or joining our mailing list today.

Start Free Trial

Already a subscriber? Log in

Latest Releases
Join the conversation

Liz Bee 2 September 2021

I truly adored reading your posting [url="https://austintxnewbornphotographer.com/"]newborn photographers near me[/url]

killer smile 2 September 2021

It was so good to see you acknowledging this topic, it really feels great. Thanks for sharing such a valuable information which is very hard to find normally. I have subscribed to your website and will be promoting it to my friends and other people as well.
[url=https://greenbayweddingphotographers.com/]wedding photography green bay wi[/url]

Bevis ruby 11 September 2019

We have radio talk shows, television with its 24-hour news cycle, and video and photos on the internet, all presenting emotions vividly to vast numbers of listeners and viewers. gameplay [url=https://clickerheroes.co]clicker heroes[/url]