Personality tests misunderstand you

The dark side of self-diagnosis

Online personality tests are replacing genuine introspection, argues Gerardo Viera. Our need for simple explanations for our behaviours and psychology misses the complexities that shape them. These self-diagnoses can be dangerous, too; they can warp the very thing they attempt to name.

 

“Are you extroverted?” This question came up with some friends the other day, and someone mentioned a heuristic that is meant to answer the question. If you find social interactions energising, then you’re an extrovert. If you find social interactions draining, then you’re an introvert. After reassuring each other that we didn’t find each other draining, we realised that the simple heuristic couldn’t answer our question. Like most people, we all found some interactions draining while others energising. If we wanted to answer this question, to say something definitive about ourselves, then we would have to turn to another source of evidence. Luckily, a few of us had already taken online tests that located us somewhere between the extremes of introversion and extroversion, so we had our answers.

___

It might seem unusual that we need help from tests to answer questions about our psychology, but it’s not so odd that we should resort to tests to gain this self-knowledge.

___

This sort of scenario, if not the details, should be familiar. With the help of social media, the internet has enabled a personality testing industry (worth more than $2 billion) to flourish. These tests promise to help us understand what sort of people we are and provide insight into why we behave the way we do. They tell us where we sit on the autism spectrum, our Myers-Briggs personality type, whether we’re imagistic thinkers, our risk aversion, our ADHD status, and how we approach romantic relationships.

Continue reading

Enjoy unlimited access to the world's leading thinkers.

Start by exploring our subscription options or joining our mailing list today.

Start Free Trial

Already a subscriber? Log in

Latest Releases
Join the conversation

帅 梁 25 April 2024

if i can't