The Age of Nothing

Is there something missing in our lives?

So far as I know, Jürgen Habermas set the ball rolling. In 2008 he wrote a celebrated essay, ‘An Awareness of What is Missing: Faith and Reason in a Post-Secular Age.’ The thrust of what he had to say first occurred to him after he had attended a memorial service for Max Frisch, the Swiss author and playwright, which was held in St. Peter’s Church in Zurich as long ago as April 9, 1991. The service began with Karin Pilliod, Frisch’s partner, reading out a brief declaration written by the deceased. It stated, among other things: ‘We let our nearest speak, and without an “amen”. I am grateful to the ministers of St. Peter’s in Zurich … for their permission to place the coffin in the church during our memorial service. The ashes will be strewn somewhere.’ Two friends spoke but there was no priest and no blessing. The mourners were made up mostly of people who had little time for church and religion. Frisch himself had drawn up the menu for the meal that followed.

Habermas wrote much later (in 2008) that, at the time, the ceremony did not strike him as unusual but that, as the years passed, he came to the view that the form, place and progression of the service were odd. ‘Clearly, Max Frisch, an agnostic, who rejected any profession of faith, had sensed the awkwardness of non-religious burial practices and, by his choice of place, publicly declared that the enlightened modern age has failed to find a suitable replacement for a religious way of coping with the final rîte de passage which brings life to a close.’ And this more than a hundred years since Nietzsche announced the death of God.

Habermas went on to use this event – Frisch’s memorial – as the basis for his essay, ‘An Awareness of What is Missing.’ In this effort he traces the development of thought from the Axial Age to the Modern period and argues that, while ‘the cleavage between secular knowledge and revealed knowledge cannot be bridged’, the fact that religious traditions are, or were in 2008, an ‘unexhausted force’, must mean that they are based more on reason than secular critics allow and this ‘reason’, he thought, lies in religion’s appeal to what he called ‘solidarity’, the idea of a ‘moral whole’, a world of collectively binding ideals, ‘the idea of the Kingdom of God on earth’. It is this, he said, that contrasts successfully with secular reason, and provides the ‘awkward’ awareness of something that is missing. In effect, he said that the main monotheisms had taken several ideas from classical Greece – Athens as much as Jerusalem – and based their appeal on Greek reason as much as on faith: this is one reason why they have endured.

Habermas has one of the most fertile, yet idiosyncratic and provocative minds of the post-World War Two conversation but his ideas on this score are underlined by, as I see it, an increasing number of contemporaries, all of whom seem to think that there is something missing in our lives.

Continue reading

Enjoy unlimited access to the world's leading thinkers.

Start by exploring our subscription options or joining our mailing list today.

Start Free Trial

Already a subscriber? Log in

Latest Releases
Join the conversation

Abraham Joseph 2 July 2017

A typical ' scholastic essay', with so many quotes and references, 'a cooking up of evidence to prove the theory already in hand' ( what is inverted comas, by Dr.Whitefield)
The sense of 'something is missing' is not exclusive to men in life,but it troubles open minded and deep searching Scientists too; the 'missing link' is famous.- - -they all feel, there exists a unified theory, that would link all the known forms of energies one day!

This lingering 'sense' is the work of man's not yet recognized 'hidden sense organ of Reason'; we have it, but we have not yet recognized it! When Science opens up one day, it will revolutionalize
our theory of knowledge! Love to share here,two blogs; one how inadequate our knowledge of Logic and Reason, and the next, why we should get ready to accept the 'sense organ' role of our faculty of Reason: http://thesparkleofhumanreason.blogspot.in/2016/07/why-our-understanding-of-logic-needs.html
http://philosopherskorner.blogspot.in/

David Morey 2 20 August 2015

Looking forward to reading this, Peter Watson is always good value.