The faces of faceless people

How reporting ‘refugees’ went wrong

 ‘Refugees’ have become a political football, a moral calling and a constant source of sensationalist news stories. But the identity of these people – university professors, electricians, mothers, sports enthusiasts – is often deliberately avoided. Hearing refugees speak for themselves transforms how we think of people who have fled their homelands. Journalists must set pre-formed narratives aside and tell these real stories, writes Glenda Cooper.

 

Abdulwahab Tahhan did an English literature degree, is a stand-up comedian in his spare time, has written for the Guardian and last year made an award-winning podcast. Like many British people, he loves to drink tea and complain about the weather – and loathes the idea of camping.

He is also a refugee from Syria. But that fact alone should not define him. 

I first met Abdul in 2019 when he took part in a podcast we were doing at City University of London as part of an event about refugees which aimed to give those who’d sought refuge in this country the chance to speak themselves, rather than being simply reported on.

It seemed a pressing issue to cover.  In the past decade, the debate around refugees, asylum seekers, immigrants and migrants has become increasingly charged. Donald Trump credited his tough stance on refugees with helping him to win the US presidency; asylum seekers were also one of the most salient issues during the Brexit referendum, with migrants being portrayed as both economic and security threats.

Lack of voice maintains a difference between ‘us’ and ‘them’ and leaves them as two-dimensional figures or groups.

Key to this is the role the news media plays, and the identities (or lack of them) that they bestow on refugees. Many academic papers have detailed how refugees are portrayed in the media  – as dangerous criminals, security risks or taking up limited health, education or social care resources if they are here in the UK. If abroad, they are often portrayed as helpless victims of disaster or war. Rarely are they given their own identity – that they might also be also a university lecturer, a doctor or accountant, that they have families and a long history.

Part of the problem is the lack of voice. During a research project with colleagues at City, we looked at how often refugees’ voices are directly heard in UK online and print coverage a couple of years after the 2015 refugee crisis. Similar to previous studies which had looked at the crisis itself, we found that public sector workers and politicians were far more likely to be quoted than refugees themselves. In total, public officials were quoted in 79.7% of articles, while refugees, asylum seekers, immigrants and migrants were used as a source in 21.6% of articles.

Why does this matter? Lack of voice means that it is far easier for us to ‘other’ refugees; to see them as causing problems rather than bringing opportunities. It maintains a difference between ‘us’ and ‘them’ and leaves them as two-dimensional figures or groups, known only by a label and a set of pre-formed, narrow narratives.

But when we get to see people beyond their immigration status, our perception changes. We looked at how refugees in the UK were portrayed as opposed to other parts of the world. When the UK media wrote about those who were currently in the UK, the topics were political: Brexit, social issues and culture. The coverage of those who are closer to home reflected concerns around integration into British culture. There was also a more sympathetic approach to refuges in the UK compared to those in foreign countries. Stories about violence towards refugees, asylum seekers, immigrants and migrants were statistically higher than would be expected – when newspapers/websites write about individuals close to home they are more likely to give an empathetic view.

This aligns with the coverage of the 24 Syrian families who settled on the small Scottish island of Bute. Despite some suspicion to begin with, those who settled in Bute have integrated into local schools, and opened a Syrian barber shop, restaurant and patisseries - and there have been multiple stories and documentaries about these success stories.

In contrast, when the UK media wrote about refugees in Europe, the topics of terrorism and violence perpetrated by refugees, asylum seekers, immigrants and migrants were statistically higher than would be expected – perhaps reflecting the succession of terror attacks in France in 2016 and 2017 and the controversy over rapes and sexual assaults allegedly perpetrated by asylum seekers in Cologne in New Year 2015/6.  Yet, while terrorist attacks have often been blamed on asylum seekers, only 5% of those responsible for attacks in Europe and North America between 2014 and 2017 were asylum seekers or refugees.

Conversely however, even coverage with the best of intentions can also have a detrimental effect. The documentary Another News Story looked at the refugee crisis of 2015 – but turned its focus on the journalists themselves.  It details the journalists’ desire to ensure the story makes the news headlines. But the kind of decisions they make – particularly whether there are more sympathetic ‘types’ of refugee to focus on, challenges not only the way the media themselves cover these stories, but highlights our own prejudices as viewers and readers too. While many pieces will concentrate on sympathetic shots of women and children, in fact most refugees and survivors of humanitarian disasters are men, as was the case in the 2004 tsunami.  

And some journalists have been loathe to talk about the realities of life as a refugee – by which I mean the importance of phones. There has been criticism over how ‘needy’ a refugee really is if they still have access to a smartphone – but research shows that when refugees arrived in Lesvos, what they wanted was not food or water but the chance to charge their mobiles in order to find their families, get access to jobs and money and use tracking systems to find a safe way.

It is worthwhile to think about how people’s identities evolve and change; that migration status is a person’s single, defining feature.

So how can we improve the way we report refugees? Can we get away from an opaque label that blurs individual identities into a homogenous group? Here, the Ethical Journalism Network’s five-point plan on migration reporting is key. It warns against over-simplification, acting independently from narratives that stem from politics or emotion and ensuring migrant voices are heard. Added to that the International Federation of the Red Cross and Red Crescent’s Code of Conduct for covering humanitarian disasters also states that disaster victims should be treated as “dignified human beings not hopeless objects”.

Finally, it is worthwhile to think about how people’s identities evolve and change; that migration status is a person’s single, defining feature. While the media plays an important part, as members of the public we also need to realise this. In Abdulwahab’s podcast Integrate That!, the most gripping parts were not about what happened to him and his guests when fleeing their home countries, but how they managed their lives in a new one – finding jobs, the challenge of making new friends and the darkly humorous experience of being told to ‘enjoy the moment’ by well-meaning people when you have just escaped a country with only the clothes you stood up in.

These are just some of the unique, human experiences and identities hidden behind the single term ‘refugee.’    

Latest Releases
Join the conversation

ida sanka 2 September 2021

I appreciate your blog post and the content you shared with us is simply wonderful [url="https://mortgagelendersmaconga.com"]current mortgage rates[/url]

killer smile 2 September 2021

This is exactly what I was looking for. Thank God I found this site! Thanks for sharing this
[url=https://deckbuildersboise.com/]deck builders boise [/url]

killer smile 2 September 2021

interesting blog! keep posting more! [url=https://bathroomremodelboise.com]bathroom renovation boise id[/url]

Albina Muro 30 August 2021

This is a good post. This post gives truly quality information. I’m definitely going to look into it. Really very useful tips are provided here. Thank you so much. Keep up the good works. [url=https://liguelimousinpaintball.xooit.fr/t380-Peeler-Blueprint-Kenshi-to-Start-in-the-World-of-Kitchen-Acc.htm#p1148]kenshi how to get peeler[/url]

Albina Muro 30 August 2021

This is a good post. This post gives truly quality information. I’m definitely going to look into it. Really very useful tips are provided here. Thank you so much. Keep up the good works. <a href="https://liguelimousinpaintball.xooit.fr/t380-Peeler-Blueprint-Kenshi-to-Start-in-the-World-of-Kitchen-Acc.htm#p1148">kenshi how to get peeler</a>

dubai maids 14 August 2021

When maid agencies absolutely are a dime a number of, the field in Dubai will not be highly regulated and you simply must you should never be utilized. Understand just what exactly certifications cleaning service companies currently have. You may possibly check once they have a strong ISO documentation or once they are recorded under Dubai's Unit of Global financial Development. Also endure their website word by word and observe many affiliates of staff they may have, how long they are in business, whether they may have uniforms et cetera - these details will assist you to gauge once they are actually experienced. Find a proper street address with your landline selection. If attainable, drop around. [url=https://www.springcleaning.ae/]https://www.springcleaning.ae/[/url]

dubai maids 14 August 2021

High quality cleaning vendors hire and additionally train employees to discover what top cleaning systems are hygienic, where they practice all of these standards in just about every home individuals clean. You will definitely find the family comes with less your own allergies, colds and additionally ailments after a cleaning service is actually hired to address your place. <a href="https://www.springcleaning.ae/">cleaning companies dubai</a>

Albina Muro 11 August 2021

Nice post. I was checking constantly this blog and I am impressed! Extremely helpful information specially the last part I care for such info a lot. I was seeking this particular information for a very long time. Thank you and good luck. [url=https://normalizegreatness.com/]growth mindset speaker[/url]

Albina Muro 11 August 2021

Nice post. I was checking constantly this blog and I am impressed! Extremely helpful information specially the last part I care for such info a lot. I was seeking this particular information for a very long time. Thank you and good luck. <a href="https://normalizegreatness.com/">growth mindset speaker</a>

geometry dash 10 August 2021

Thanks for sharing your precious time to create this post, It is so informative and the content makes the post more interesting. really appreciated.
[url=https://geometrydashfree.com/] geometry dash[/url]

Albina Muro 9 August 2021

This is a good post. This post gives truly quality information. I’m definitely going to look into it. Really very useful tips are provided here. Thank you so much. Keep up the good works. [url=https://normalizegreatness.com/]Leadership Quotes[/url]

Albina Muro 3 August 2021

Wonderful blog! I found it while surfing around on Yahoo News. Do you have any suggestions on how to get listed in Yahoo News? I’ve been trying for a while but I never seem to get there! Appreciate it. [url=http://monsieurclub.com/medical-billing-and-credentialing-services/]acute medical services billing[/url]

jones Elizabeth 27 July 2021

That gives off an impression of being fabulous anyway i am still not very beyond any doubt that I like it. At any rate will look much more into it and choose by and by! <b><a href="https://oremanga.net/">oremanga</a></b>

jones Elizabeth 15 July 2021

Excellent article plus its information and I positively bookmark to this site because here I always get an amazing knowledge as I expect. Thanks for this to share with us
[url=https://www.thepollencollections.com/]Pollen Collection[/url]

jones Elizabeth 15 July 2021

Great post full of useful tips! My site is fairly new and I am also having a hard time getting my readers to leave comments. Analytics shows they are coming to the site but I have a feeling “nobody wants to be first”.
[url=https://www.belgraviasace.com.sg/]Belgravia Ace[/url]

jones Elizabeth 15 July 2021

This is my first time visit to your blog and I am very interested in the articles that you serve. Provide enough knowledge for me. Thank you for sharing useful and don't forget, keep sharing useful info:
[url=https://www.bartleysvue.sg/]Bartley Vue[/url]

jones Elizabeth 15 July 2021

This is my first time visit to your blog and I am very interested in the articles that you serve. Provide enough knowledge for me. Thank you for sharing useful and don't forget, keep sharing useful info: <a href="https://www.bartleysvue.sg/">Bartley Vue</a>

jones Elizabeth 15 July 2021

It is imperative that we read blog post very carefully. I am already done it and find that this post is really amazing.
[url=https://thecommodores.com.sg/]The Commodore[/url]

jones Elizabeth 15 July 2021

Regular visits listed here are the easiest method to appreciate your energy, which is why why I am going to the website everyday, searching for new, interesting info. Many, thank you
[url=https://www.thewatergardens.sg/]Watergardens at Canberra[/url]

jones Elizabeth 15 July 2021

Regular visits listed here are the easiest method to appreciate your energy, which is why why I am going to the website everyday, searching for new, interesting info. Many, thank you <a href="https://www.thewatergardens.sg/">Watergardens at Canberra</a>

haven haven 8 July 2021

There's a lot of new and exciting things to explore. [url=https://happywheelsbest.com]happy wheels[/url] online

jones Elizabeth 1 July 2021

Excellent article plus its information and I positively bookmark to this site because here I always get an amazing knowledge as I expect. Thanks for this to share with us
[url=https://eudocsexpress.com/passport/]Deutsch[/url]

jones Elizabeth 1 July 2021

Excellent article plus its information and I positively bookmark to this site because here I always get an amazing knowledge as I expect. Thanks for this to share with us <a href="https://eudocsexpress.com/passport/">Deutsch</a>

muneer ahmed 24 June 2021

The first phase the preparation should, theoretically, be uninfluenced by the intended intensity and duration of the sound which is subsequently produced. In fact, however, so quickly are the three phases accomplished that the pianist rarely has capacity to think, in performance, of each phase separately.
[url=https://www.probeautyaesthetics.com/]aqualyx buy online[/url]

jones Elizabeth 18 June 2021

Thanks a lot for sharing us about this update. Hope you will not get tired on making posts as informative as this. <b><a href="https://n.b5z.net/i/u/10239294/f/What_Merchant_Services_ISOs_and_Credit_Card_Processing_ISOs_Should_Provide_Thier_Sales_Agents.pdf">merchant services sales tips</a></b>

jones Elizabeth 18 June 2021

Awesome review, I am a major devotee to remarking on web journals to educate the web journal scholars realize that they've added something beneficial to the internet!..
[url=https://profidokumente.com/]Buy Certificates Online UK[/url]

jones Elizabeth 18 June 2021

Awesome review, <a href="https://profidokumente.com/">Buy Certificates Online UK</a> I am a major devotee to remarking on web journals to educate the web journal scholars realize that they've added something beneficial to the internet!..

muneer ahmed 14 June 2021

definately enjoy every little bit of it and [url=https://the-pasirris8.com/]Pasir Ris 8[/url] I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff of your blog a must read blog!

muneer ahmed 14 June 2021

definately enjoy every little bit of it and <a href="https://the-pasirris8.com/">Pasir Ris 8</a> I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff of your blog a must read blog!

jones Elizabeth 12 June 2021

Thanks a lot for sharing us about this update. Hope you will not get tired on making posts as informative as this. [url=https://www.อ่านทั้งวัน.com/]นิยาย pdf[/url]

James Curtis 12 June 2021

Do you want to find fresh facts and data about 99papers, including its pricing policy? I recommend you to check out this 99papers prices review. https://essayservices.review/reviews/99papers-review