news

more

What they won't teach you at university

The danger of group-think academics

Issue 95, 9th March 2021
| Research fellow at the Centre for the History of the Emotions at Queen Mary, University of London.
1,302 words
Read time: approx. 7 mins

The university system has a vice-hold grip on what we consider ‘true’. However, academia has for a long time only served a materialistic picture of the universe, and so ‘truth’ really just means ‘scientific materialism’. This state of play is kept going in universities by a culture of group-think, dogma and disenchantment – where student well-being is left by the waste side, writes Jules Evans.

 

‘Esalen existed in the liminal space between academia and the counterculture.’

So reads a line in Jeffrey Kripal’s history of Esalen, where he’s the director of the Centre for Research. It made me think of my own relationship to academia.

Esalen is a place in Big Sur, California, set up in 1962, which offers week and weekend-long courses, mainly in personal growth. It is like an alternative college, exploring topics that academia was scared to touch (ecstatic experiences, psychedelics, alternative medicine etc), but also exploring new ways of knowing, beyond the lecture format, like the encounter session, the trip. Why did it require a non-academic college to explore these ideas?

Academia has a kind of vice-hold on western culture, and on what is designated ‘truth’. It has one dominant mind-set — rational-intellectual and resolutely secular; one main method of learning — the lecture; and one main method of evaluation — the exam. Its culture was defined by the sociologist Max Weber, in his very influential lecture of 1917, ‘Science as a Vocation’.

Weber insisted that academia must be committed to the search for objective rational truth. It must have no other values than that. It must resist the temptation to serve other gods, such as happiness or wisdom. The lecture room must not become a church pulpit, he insisted.

This defence of the objectivity of academia sounds heroic but was in fact profoundly disingenuous. Academic culture is not a ‘view from nowhere’. Weber was deeply committed to one view, one ideology — secular naturalism — and he envisaged academics as foot-soldiers for the advance of this ideology. Academia is, for him, a machine for disenchantment. That dogma academics are very much encouraged and expected to preach. In fact, it is so all-encompassing it is simply taken for granted.

Academia has a kind of vice-hold on western culture, and on what is designated ‘truth'.

Jules Evans
Issue 95, 9th March 2021

Continue reading

Enjoy unlimited access to the world's leading thinkers.

Start by exploring our subscription options or joining our mailing list today.

Start Free Trial

Already a subscriber? Log in

Latest Releases

The dawn of machine consciousness with Joscha Bach

Something for nothing

Francis Fukuyama warns Trump is not a realist

Join the conversation

frederick gragg 7 June 2022

The education is necessary because through this you become an expert and get acknowledge about different important aspects. Education software will help children and elders to teach themselves reading, writing and arithmetic skills. Examcollection AZ-104 VCE provides authentic IT Certification exams preparation material guaranteed to make you pass in the first attempt.

Sweet Parker 19 April 2022

That's one of the greatest problems of humanity to believe that there's only one right solution for the problem, political systems and especially education (politicians use it as an instrument of) is not an exception. Of course in the hyper globalized world the reality changes fast, while all of us, including academic institutions, have to accommodate to it quickly as well. The latter never happens and when it does, then it's too late. Collective response to cope with global pandemics and unpreparedness of all the education system might serve as a good example to prove that assumption. As a result I've searching for programming tutors at AssignmentCore up until the end of my BA computer engineering studies. That was too expensive to say at least, and is it really worth it? Not sure.

Dominic Praed 28 December 2021

I am sure that both college and university can give and teach you a lot that is useful and important, but most of it lies on the shoulders of the student since self-development and self-study are important. I've always disliked writing papers for college, but my friend advised me to read the StudyMoose review, here is the link to it, which eventually helped me to better understand the strengths and weaknesses of many software services. writing an essay, and taught me how not to be deceived by scammers.

falakshairr falakshairr 24 June 2021

good [url=https://u.osu.edu/zagorsky.1/2015/02/23/eliminatetipping/]work[/url]
<a href="https://u.osu.edu/zagorsky.1/2015/02/23/eliminatetipping/">post</a>
[post](https://u.osu.edu/zagorsky.1/2015/02/23/eliminatetipping/)

jack nelson 8 April 2021

I learned a lot at the university and this helped me build a good career in the future. I am grateful to this service [url=https://literaturereviewwritingservice.com/]literature review service[/url]. It helped me in writing various reports and articles on physics and mathematics, but there are also other topics here. After all, the university is a good school of life.

Vyacheslav Dianov 12 March 2021

The problem with all these conversations is that they, without understanding the foundations of the universe, in fact do not say anything.
Science, not having an objective knowledge of the world, misunderstands a person!

Helga Holl 12 March 2021

Undeniable quality, transparency of the policies, affordability, and availability of services are the features that help https://homeworkfor.me/ stand out from the crowd. The unlimited number of return customers (including me) is the best proof.