Free will or no free will, punishment is justified

The topic of free will continues to be a hotbed for discussion and disagreement. The most pressing questions remain: What is free will? And how does it affect the notion of moral responsibility? Here, Derk Pereboom and Dana Nelkin tussle over this issue, and disagree on whether we possess sufficient free will to hold us morally responsible. In spite of this, however, they both assert that we can maintain a stable criminal justice system in which punishment plays a prominent role.


In Defence of Free Will: Dana Nelkin

I believe that at least much of the time we act freely and in such a way that we are morally responsible for our actions and their consequences.  This means that we are eligible to be blameworthy or praiseworthy.  When you decided to read this article, you likely did so freely.  When you expended some effort to help someone else just for their sake, you were likely morally responsible f

Continue reading

Enjoy unlimited access to the world's leading thinkers.

Start by exploring our subscription options or joining our mailing list today.

Start Free Trial

Already a subscriber? Log in

Join the conversation

patrick maina 26 May 2022

Here is my story. grateful
My wife was diagnosed with a cancer, ( before i learnt of Rick Simpsons oil
/ RSO ) the hospital said to do chemotherapy and radiotherapy.. she did..
and went through a lot.. but no cure, after a while the doctors said the
cancer was spreading and we could look for alternatives.. i searched the
internet and found out about the oil.. asked a lot of questions.. watched
the videos etc.. we made the oil our selves but it couldn't just work out
we were doing more harm than good and the cancer was still there spreading,
i searched more on the internet i found a testimony on how a lady got the
oil via a website: naturalricksimpsoncannabisoil. com
immediately copied the email address on the website: i wrote to the very email
on the website: naturalricksimpsoncannabisoil. com and in an hour later i
got a reply back asking me some few questions, and enlightened me on how to
get the oil in the next 48hours, i placed my order and in the next 48hours
the medication oil got to us. immediately my wife started using the oil, it
been two months now, since my wife has been using the medication oil and
the cancerous problems are gone this very fact was clarified by the doctor.

i put up this piece of testimony for the sake of those once who need this
oil to please don't die in silence their is a cure for your cancer today
website: naturalricksimpsoncannabisoil. com and get the oil.