The AI ethics hoax

AI machines having moral worth of their own is a sci-fi fantasy

The idea that Artificial Intelligence (AI) machines should have any moral status of their own or could one day become conscious is a sci-fi fantasy. Ethical concerns about the use of AI in fields like healthcare and finance are legitimate. But we should not worry about conscious AI suffering, because machines are not, and will never be, conscious writes Tim Crane. Read Thomas Metzinger's original article here.

 

The recent opening of an Institute for Ethics in AI at the University of Oxford is decisive proof, if any were needed, that AI ethics is now ‘A Thing’. The Oxford institute will address ethical questions about the use of AI in (e.g.) healthcare, finance, the law, in changing the way in which we relate to work — and many other things besides. AI is now becoming so dominant in our lives (whether we realise it or not) and its ethical implications in all these areas are not well-understood. It is good news that philosophers and others are addressing these questions seriously.

metzinger with text2 SUGGESTED READING Why we should worry about computer suffering By Thomas Metzinger However, it is common to find discussions of AI these days addressing even more ambitious questions. For example: what should we do if the machines become smarter than us? What happens if AI machines develop their own values, and these values conflict with ours? How should we treat these AI machines if they become conscious? What should their moral status be?

The problem with questions like this is not that they make no sense, but rather that their immediate sci-fi appeal can obscure the really urgent practical questions about AI and its implications. There is nothing wrong with speculations about machine consciousness or the moral status of machines as such — as a philosopher, I could hardly object to them. But some thinkers give the impression that these are questions of the same kind as the questions about AI in healthcare, finance and so on, or (even worse) that the answers to the sci-fi questions are required in order to answer the practical questions about real AI. The truth, it seems to me, is that the answers to these sci-fi questions are of no relevance to the real ethical questions, and that they are a distraction from real AI ethics.

The truth is that the answers to these sci-fi questions are a distraction from real AI ethics.

Take the idea of machines becoming ‘smarter’ than us. Anyone with the slightest familiarity with recent AI will know that AI machines are already smarter than us. AI machines have for some time been far better than humans at chess, they have beaten the world champion of Go, they are much better than most of us at remembering phone numbers, searching documents for information, finding the best route to your destination on public transport, and (of course) at mathematical calculations. They are computers, after all, and that’s what computers do — compute.

But of course, this is not what people mean when they talk about the machines becoming smarter. They mean that an AI might become ‘smart’ in the way that we are smart, but perhaps to an even higher degree. It might be able to think, to reason, to make decisions, to be creative, inventive, witty, reasonable, sensitive to other creatures and… whatever else it is that we are talking about when we say that someone is smart or intelligent.

Continue reading

Enjoy unlimited access to the world's leading thinkers.

Start by exploring our subscription options or joining our mailing list today.

Start Free Trial

Already a subscriber? Log in

Latest Releases
Join the conversation

james peter 15 November 2021

bestmessage.info

james peter 15 November 2021

bestmesaage.info

John Smith 16 21 August 2021

Nice Post!

I have also read about the A.I. sex robots. I have seen some robots like them, here: https://www.lovedollpalace.com/

james zen 5 August 2021

It's so great!
fall guys: https://fallguys3.com

Dima Santarskyi 5 July 2021

If you've ever thought about starting a business - stop thinking, and do it! Recently I opened my own IT company and I needed developers to help me create a project. The [url=https://hireukrainiandevelopers.com/blog/how-to-hire-php-developers/]hire php developer ukraine[/url] service helped me in this. Perfect price-quality ratio. I recommend them.

Sara R Johanson 29 May 2021

Commenting on a blog is an art. Good comments create relations. You’re doing great work. Keep it up. I am a professional blogger thanks.
You may visit my latest post related to Improve Typing Speed With This 5 Effective Tips. I will really appreciate our visit to https://microphonecrat.wordpress.com/2021/05/11/improve-typing-speed-with-this-5-effective-tips Thank for your concern.

Sara R Johanson 29 May 2021

Very nice… I really like your blog. Such a great information for blogger and it help me a lot to improve my article.
You can also visit article written by me to learn about The best free speech to text software to Boost your working speed. This is the latest post I have written with lot of efforts on researching. Please do visit https://eduglobeai.blogspot.com/2021/04/best-free-speech-to-text-software.html and comment your views.

Sara R Johanson 29 May 2021

Very nice… I really like your blog. Such a great information for blogger and it help me a lot to improve my article.
You can also visit article written by me to learn about voice reorganization technology. This is the latest post I have written with lot of efforts on researching. Please do visit <a href ="https://eduglobeai.blogspot.com/2021/04/best-free-speech-to-text-software.html">The best free speech to text software to Boost your working speed</a> and comment your views.

Janne Moriggan 13 March 2021

Informative article
I was searching for this information on <a href=https://www.google.com/>google</a>

Sean Matthews 9 March 2021

A fair number of claims there. But not many arguments to back them up that I can see.

Essay UK 9 March 2021

https://www.stunxt.com/blogs/3954/Guidelines-To-Complete-A-Descriptive-Essay-Writing
https://www.isound.co.nz/read-blog/701
https://www.thepostcity.com/how-to-get-ready-for-final-examinations/
https://www.1upfun.com/post/1331627/complete-essay-writing-in-five-basic-steps
https://www.bhitmagazine.com.ng/writers/step%e2%80%8c-%e2%80%8cby%e2%80%8c-%e2%80%8cstep%e2%80%8c-%e2%80%8cinstructions%e2%80%8c-%e2%80%8cfor%e2%80%8c-%e2%80%8creflective%e2%80%8c-%e2%80%8cessay%e2%80%8c-%e2%80%8cwriting%e2%80%8c-%e2%80%8c/
https://www.articleted.com/article/346141/83070/Basic-Guidelines-For-Cause-And-Effect-Essay-Writing