The Stoic self

An eminently practical take on who we are

What is the self? As with any complex and slippery concept, we can draw on literally thousands of years worth of philosophical discussions in both the eastern and western traditions to address the question. But perhaps it will be simpler to begin with two contrasting definitions from a dictionary:

In philosophy:

The ego; that which knows, remembers, desires, suffers, etc., as contrasted with that known, remembered, etc.

The uniting principle, as a soul, underlying all subjective experience.

Setting aside metaphysically questionable talk of "soul," it should be obvious that there is such thing as the self. We do "know, remember, desire, suffer, etc.," and we do have unified subjective experiences. Whatever turns out to make that possible is the self.

This, however, doesn't mean that the self is a stable entity, or a specific thing located somewhere inside our brain. Nor, certainly, is there any reason to believe that -- whatever it is -- it will survive our physical demise.

The most "skeptical" conception of the self in western literature is usually attributed to David Hume. In his A Treatise of Human Nature he famously wrote: "I may venture to affirm of the rest of mankind, that they are nothing but a bundle or collection of different perceptions, which succeed each other with inconceivable rapidity, and are in a perpetual flux and movement."

The Stoic take on what constitutes the self is eminently practical and - when properly understood - can dramatically change our life.

This turns out to be analogous to the oft-mentioned Buddhist notion of anatta, or no-self. Contra popular understanding, however, this is not a statement that there is no self, but more precisely that there are no essential or unchanging things that constitute our selves.

By contrast, the Stoics are often presented as putting forth an essential conception of the self. I do not think this is correct, as the Stoic notion is actually similar to the Buddhist one as well as the one put forth by Hume. Moreover, the Stoic take on what constitutes the self is eminently practical and -- when properly understood -- can dramatically change our life. For the better.

To explore the issue, let us consider two prominent figures that have shaped Stoic thinking and continue to do so: the Pre-Socratic philosopher Heraclitus, and the early second century Stoic philosopher Epictetus.

Continue reading

Enjoy unlimited access to the world's leading thinkers.

Start by exploring our subscription options or joining our mailing list today.

Start Free Trial

Already a subscriber? Log in

Latest Releases
Join the conversation

Hermione Stone 14 October 2023

thanks for the update here.

Aliko Chio 21 January 2022

The Stoic Stoics believed that the only way to achieve anything worthwhile is to do it alone, but do it well. They said that one can never achieve what they want if they pursue their own desires first and forget about others. Instead of achieving something great, enjoy it and stop chasing after a quick win. Gambling is a game where people make money with gambling on the table and hope for the best. The is inspiring many successful people in different fields such as sportsmen, musicians, entrepreneurs and bankers to be prepared for life’s challenges by not risking too much money or time.

Carter Julian 28 March 2021

It is the dynamic process of science because science is growing day after day with the hard work of scientists who are working for it. The structures of <a href="https://artdaily.com/news/131321/Writing-as-a-kind-of-art#.X-HGWWgzaUm">https://artdaily.com/news/131321/Writing-as-a-kind-of-art#.X-HGWWgzaUm</a> might get the importance. The scientists may think about it and make a search plan because it is possible to do it by heart.

Lorivers Mendoza 24 August 2020

The stoic self on an eminently practical. Really hard for me to complete this work because i don't know when it gone to be complete and when https://www.dissertationhqhelp.com/payforessay-net-review-5-10/ are doing such plans which are talk about the most. We can make more plans for doing our working hard.

William Riley 17 August 2020

I think this blog I found from this website which is on “The Stoic self” should read maximum peoples. It’s really amazing blog.
Regards, William. http://eliteassignment.co.uk/human-resource-management-Coursework-help/

Lorivers Mendoza 10 August 2020

The stoic self on an eminently practical. Really hard for me to complete this work because i don't know when it gone to be complete and when https://www.dissertationhqhelp.com/payforessay-net-review-5-10/ are doing such plans which are talk about the most. We can make more plans for doing our working hard.

Sarah Connor 29 July 2020

Very happy to found here unique blog which is on the stoic self. I am looking forward for more this kind of blogs.
Regards, Lauren. https://www.cvfolks.co.uk/cv-builder/

Caroline Webb 28 July 2020

Amazed to read here various full of informative blogs and thankful to an author for provide us unique blogs.
Regards, Caroline. http://www.personalstatementfolks.co.uk/economics-personal-statement/

Jack Ponting 27 July 2020

I am really very happy to found such an amazing blog from this website. I would like to bookmark this website and definitely recommend to others.
Regards, Jack. Assignment writer. http://www.qualitydissertation.co.uk/assignment-writing-help