There is no common sense about consciousness

If a tree falls in a forest...

Theories of consciousness like dualism and panpsychism often assume that conscious experiences involve acquaintance with mental qualities – qualities wholly internal to the mind. These qualities are supposed to be totally obvious to anyone who introspects, and so part of our “common sense” picture of the mind. Yet, argues Justin Sytsma, people who are untrained in analytic philosophy don’t find these qualities obvious at all. Philosophers of consciousness should therefore beware of making assertions about “common sense” in their arguments, for “common sense” turns out to be a shifting ground, even when the topic is our own mental life.

 

“In attempting to explode the myth I shall probably be taken to be denying well-known facts about the mental life of human beings, and my plea that I aim at doing nothing more than rectify the logic of mental-conduct concepts will probably be disallowed as mere subterfuge.”
(Gilbert Ryle, The Concept of Mind, 1949/2009, p. 6)

 

You’ve probably heard the following thought experiment before: If a tree falls in the woods and no one is there to hear it, does it make a sound? Indeed, this question now borders on a cliché. Nonetheless, thinking about it can offer a nice entry point into understanding a particular notion of consciousness that has played a central role in contemporary philosophy of mind. This is the notion of phenomenal consciousness. More on this in a minute.

___

Can there be unheard sounds or, similarly, unseen colors, unfelt pains, and so on?

___

So, does the tree falling make a sound or not? (Or, more generally, can there be unheard sounds or, similarly, unseen colors, unfelt pains, and so on?) Let’s set aside complications, such as that the wildlife in the forest might hear it, even if no humans are around. As such, imagine that the falling of the tree goes completely unheard.

I’ve been asking my students this question for the past decade when introducing the topic of consciousness. And, while anecdotal, I’ve observed an interesting and quite consistent pattern over the years. In my introductory courses, the overwhelming response is affirmative, often with upwards of 90% of students answering that the tree falling makes a sound. Indeed, in discussion, these students tend to treat this as rather obvious. Things start to change in my intermediate courses. While the majority still answer that the tree falling makes a sound, a sizable minority (roughly 40% give or take) deny this. This shift continues in my advanced courses, with a majority now denying that there is a sound, although a notable minority continues to give the affirmative answer. And, in discussion, the deniers – now in the majority – tend to treat this as obvious.

The orthodox philosophical and scientific response is to deny that the tree falling makes a sound. Here, for instance, is a snippet from one of the earliest discussions I could find. In the “Notes & Queries” section of Scientific American (April 5, 1884, p. 218), a reader asks our focal question. In response the editors offer an amusingly inconsistent answer: “Sound is vibration, transmitted to our senses through the mechanism of the ear, and recognized as sound only at our nerve centers. The falling of the tree or any other disturbance will produce vibration of the air. If there be no ears to hear, there will be no sound.”

related-video-image SUGGESTED VIEWING The mystery of emergence With Suchitra Sebastian, Hilary Lawson, Philip Goff, Jack Symes

Continue reading

Enjoy unlimited access to the world's leading thinkers.

Start by exploring our subscription options or joining our mailing list today.

Start Free Trial

Already a subscriber? Log in

Latest Releases
Join the conversation

Gillian Bayford 16 April 2025

I want to use this medium to share my incredible manifesting with Dr. Kachi, who truly changed my life. For a long time, I struggled with homelessness after losing my job as a nurse. Life felt like an endless battle, and I spent many years trying to win the lottery, hoping for a better future. But despite my efforts, I had no success and was growing increasingly frustrated. That was until I came across an amazing testimony from a woman named Natasha, who shared how Dr. Kachi helped her win the National EuroMillions jackpot. I had always loved playing EuroMillions, but winning seemed impossible for me. However, after seeing Natasha's story, I decided to reach out to Dr. Kachi prepared a special spell to help me with guaranteed lucky numbers. Within 24 hours, he provided me with the winning numbers and instructed me to play. To my amazement, I won £184.656 million in the EuroMillions! Thanks to Dr. Kachi, my life has been transformed, and my financial situation has changed for the better. I will never forget this joyful moment, as it has been the best thing to ever happen to me. If you’re struggling and seeking a way out, never give up. Dr. Kachi can help you, just as he helped me. Keep your faith and take a chance – your life could change too! contact email drkachispellcast @ gmail. com or his phone text or call number: +1 (209) 893-8075

Jason Cooper 8 April 2025



God bless Dr Ughulu for his marvelous work in my life, I was diagnosed of Herpes simplex virus (HSV) since 2014 and I was taking my medications, I wasn't satisfied I needed to get the Herpes simplex virus (HSV) out of my system, I did a researched about some possible cure for Herpes simplex virus (HSV) I saw a comment about Dr Ughulu, how he cured Herpes simplex virus (HSV) with his herbal medicine, I contacted him and he guided me. I asked for solutions, he started the remedy for my health, he sent me the medicine through UPS SPEED POST. I took the medicine as prescribed by Dr Ughulu and 7 days later I was totally cured from  Herpes simplex virus (HSV) thank you Dr Ughulu, get intouch with him too. WhatsApp: +1(720) 794-2516 Call Text Number: +1(252) 409-1841 Via:drughulupowerfulspelltemple@gmail. com

david sutter 6 April 2025

I already gave up on ever getting cured of HSV2 because i have try many treatment none of them work out for me i have gone to different hospital they always tell me the same thing there is no cure for herpes, when i came across a post about Dr UMA in the net from a lady called Angela i contacted her and she reassured me with his herbal medicine which i took according to the way he instructed, that how i was cured. I doubted at first because i have been to a whole lot of reputable doctors, tried a lot of medicines but none was able to cure me. so i decided to listen to him and he commenced treatment, and under two weeks i was totally free from Herpes. i want to say a very big thank you to DR UMA for what he has done in my life. feel free to leave him a message on Whats-app him +2347035619585

Bobby Liam 6 April 2025

I was diagnosed of herpes in 2019 and I tried all possible means to get cure but all to no avail until i saw a post in a health forum about a herbal doctor from Africa who prepare herbal medicine to cure all kind of diseases including herpes virus, at first i doubted if it was real but decided to give it a try, when i contact this herbal doctor via his email i bought the herpes herbal medicine and received it through DHL within 7 days and used it as prescribed, i tested negative to herpes virus within 3 weeks of usage. Thanks to Dr Ughulu His email: drughulupowerfulspelltemple@gmail. com And Calling Number: +1(252) 409-1841 Or WhatsApp: +1(720) 794-2516

david sutter 5 April 2025

I already gave up on ever getting cured of HSV2 because i have try many treatment none of them work out for me i have gone to different hospital they always tell me the same thing there is no cure for herpes, when i came across a post about Dr UMA in the net from a lady called Angela i contacted her and she reassured me with his herbal medicine which i took according to the way he instructed, that how i was cured. I doubted at first because i have been to a whole lot of reputable doctors, tried a lot of medicines but none was able to cure me. so i decided to listen to him and he commenced treatment, and under two weeks i was totally free from Herpes. i want to say a very big thank you to DR UMA for what he has done in my life. feel free to leave him a message on Whats-app him +2347035619585,

Bobby Liam 25 March 2025

I was diagnosed of herpes in 2019 and I tried all possible means to get cure but all to no avail until i saw a post in a health forum about a herbal doctor from Africa who prepare herbal medicine to cure all kind of diseases including herpes virus, at first i doubted if it was real but decided to give it a try, when i contact this herbal doctor via his email i bought the herpes herbal medicine and received it through DHL within 7 days and used it as prescribed, i tested negative to herpes virus within 3 weeks of usage. Thanks to Dr Ughulu His email: drughulupowerfulspelltemple@gmail. com And Calling Number: +1(252) 409-1841 Or WhatsApp: +1(720) 794-2516

magriet dennis 19 March 2025

Get rid of all kinds of Herpes and virus infections, Diabetes, Hepatitis A B C, Menopause and HIV with Natural Roots and Herbs, i was once infected with HERPES and after using Dr UMA Herbal Medicine for couple of weeks i couldn't trace it anymore, i even went for checkup and my test came out Negative. Get your cure today from this wonderful herbalist, Dr. UMA.
You can also reach doctor UMA on WhatsApp
+2347035619585

nelly tyson 18 March 2025

Hello everyone. Dr. Osalu Herbs is a good remedy for herpes Virus , I was a carrier of herpes virus and I saw a testimony on how Dr. Osalu cured Herpes Virus, I decided to contact him, I contacted him and he guided me. I asked him for solutions and he started the remedies for my health. After he finished he sent me the herbs which I took for 2 weeks before asking me to go for a check up and getting there. I could not believe that I was confirmed HSV 2 Negative after the test,Today I am so happy because i'm free from herpes virus with the help of Dr. Osalu Thank God now everything is fine, I'm cured by Dr. Osalu herbal medicine, I'm very thankful to God for making it possible. you can reach him on his email, i strongly recommend him to any one out here looking for a cure . drosaluherbalhome@gmail. com or call/WhatsApp +2348078668950.

nels kate 6 March 2025

I have been suffering from Herpes for the past 1 years and 8 months, and ever since then i have been taking series of treatment but there was no improvement until i came across testimonies of Dr. UMA on how he has been curing different people from different diseases all over the world, then i contacted him as well. After our conversation he sent me the medicine which i  took according .to his instructions. When i was done taking the herbal medicine i went for a medical checkup and to my greatest surprise i was cured from Herpes. My heart is so filled with joy. If you are suffering from Herpes or any other disease you can contact Dr. UMA today on whatsapp +2347035619585.

quatisha brown 14 January 2025

I just want the whole world to know about this spell caster I met two weeks ago,I cannot say everything he has done for me and my family I was going through online when I meant this wonderful man's testimony online how he won a lottery through the help of dr Ose I decided to just give it a try and my life is back to me now after i lost my job due to covid  he gave me a winning numbers to play lottery and i won 5000usd for my first play since then i have been working with him and he has been giving me numbers to play my lottery i can not write everything he has done for me if you need a lottery spell today contact him on oseremenspelltemple @ gmail. com       

Maria Helena 28 December 2024

Hello, everyone's, my name is Maria Helena from the United kingdom and I want to use this opportunity to thank Dr Ughulu for helping me to cure my Herpes disease, it has been over 2 years now I had this disease I don't even know how it got throw me, i have been going to difference hospital just to make sure I get cure and nothing works out for me, until the day I saw a comment online about how someone testify how Dr Ughulu cure her herpes disease and It was so very interesting to me, I really think about it for few minutes before I sent him a message and he said you're welcome my daughter, he list out what he will buy to work for me and also he said I shouldn't worried. I will be fine, so I really did the right thing he asked me to do. It didn't take up to three weeks until I was healed from my herpes disease, I went for a checkup and the doctor told me nothing is wrong with me. Please join me to thank Dr Ughulu. I really appreciate his good work. My God will continue to bless you forever. CALL/TEXT: +1(252) 409-1841 or email: drughulupowerfulspelltemple@gmail. com Via whatsApp: +1(720) 794-2516

Donald Ritchie 20 December 2024

This accomplishment is a significant milestone in my life. I’m highly grateful to Dr Uwaifo for casting spells for me to win $23.5 million dollars Lottery Mega Millions. I am Donald from California, my wife left me seven months ago because I couldn’t cater for her needs and that of my son anymore. Things have been so rough I can barely feed. I came across Dr Uwaifo's site and saw great testimony of people he has helped win millions of dollars, so I decided to give it a try, Dr Uwaifo told me what to do and gave me the Mega Millions winning numbers which I played and won 23.5 Million Dollars. I’m so grateful to Dr Uwaifo for this great win and I highly recommend him to you all. His text phone:+1(315) 277-2762.

Michael J Weirsky 18 December 2024


My happiest moment right now is testifying about Dr Ughulu for making me win the lottery mega millions. For over 5 years I have been playing the mega million, buying different kinds of tickets just to make sure I won. Still nothing could change for me to win. I did a little research on a google internet that's when I saw a lady who talk about Dr Ughulu at first I couldn't believe it I cut the site where I saw a testimony of Dr Ughulu, I made another research again and I still saw so many testimonies of this spell casters called Dr Ughulu, I just click his website because I have seen how people talked about him online so I contacted him and tell him I want to win the lottery mega millions, I followed his command and everything came out successfully I play the mega million game with the winning numbers Dr send to me I played it, when all results came out I was the winner. Do you believe Dr Ughulu made me win a very big amount of $273,000.000 millions dollars. Anyone who is seeking help should get his Call/Text number: +1(252) 409-1841 email: drughulupowerfulspelltemple@gmail. com whatsApp: +1(720) 794-2516

emily faye 17 December 2024

I have been suffering from Herpes for the past 1 years and 8 months, and ever since then I have been taking series of treatment but there was no improvement until I came across testimonies of Dr. Silver on how he has been curing different people from different diseases all over the world, then I contacted him as well. After our conversation he sent me the medicine which I took according to his instructions. When I was done taking the herbal medicine I went for a medical checkup and to my greatest surprise I was cured from Herpes. My heart is so filled with joy. If you are suffering from Herpes or any other disease you can contact Dr. Silver today on this Email address: drsilverhealingtemple @ gmail . com

mitchel dyck 15 December 2024

I'm sharing my experience to you on how I won the lottery, you can win the lottery fast and reliable in wherever you are in the world, Dr Lucas is a God sent, I saw so many testimonials online on how he helped people won different kinds of lottery, I never believed so I had to contact him to be sure if he's real and genuine, to my greatest surprise he helped me won the 70 million Lotto Max Jackpot in Canada, I'm Mitchel Dyck, I regularly buy the lottery tickets whenever I go to fill my truck almost all the time, Dr Lucas told me what I needed to do as he cast my spell which i followed without any mistakes, he gave me the numbers on the 2nd day of the spell and directed me on how to play and I really won with the numbers he gave me, I can't explain all of my experience with Dr Lucas, you can review about my winnings online then give Dr Lucas a try and watch how you will win, Email him on Drlucasspelltemple@gmail. com or WhatsApp him on +234 904 794 3567 You'll never regret contacting Dr Lucas

Ricardo Ching 1 November 2024

I am thrilled to share my testimony as a lottery jackpot winner! With the guidance and assistance of Prophet Isaac, I was able to win various amounts in the Powerball lottery. I first won $10,000, then $50,000, and finally, the incredible jackpot of $1,000,000! Prophet Isaac's insights and blessings truly made all the difference in my life, and I am forever grateful for his help. For those seeking a positive change in their luck or fortunes, I highly recommend reaching out to Prophet Isaac. You can contact him via Email: urgentspellcast01@gmail. com , WhatsApp: +1 (757) 237-1724. You can as well check out his website or Facebook page.

Trust me, your life could change for the better just like mine did!

Pamela Grant 31 October 2024

As a lottery jackpot winner, I am beyond grateful for the incredible blessings that have come my way. With the help of Prophet Isaac, my life has been forever changed. I won various amounts in the Powerball lottery, starting with a significant sum of $1 million, followed by $500,000, and ending with $100,000. Prophet Isaac's guidance and support were crucial in this journey to success, and I cannot thank him enough for his assistance. For anyone seeking guidance in their endeavors, I highly recommend reaching out to Prophet Isaac for his powerful spells and insight. Contact Prophet Isaac via email at urgentspellcast01@gmail. com or through WhatsApp at +1 (757) 237-1724 to experience the incredible transformation in your life.

Becky Bell 30 October 2024

My name is Becky Bell, from Washington, I got the chance to win $756.6 million mega million jackpot last year (2023) with the help of Dr Uwaifo spell casting. I contacted him after seeing testimonies of some people he has helped win millions of dollars through the use of his spell casting gift, he gave me the winning numbers to play on the mega million draw day, I did exactly what he instructed me to do, and I won the price tag of $756.6 million dollars. You too can stand the chance to win millions of dollars by contacting him with this phone number: +1(315) 277-2762 /email: druwaifospelltemple@gmail. com

Harry Jones 29 October 2024


My name is Harry. I'm very happy to share my testimonies. The best thing that has ever happened in my life is how I won the lottery. I am a man who believes that one day I will win the lottery. Finally my dreams came through when I emailed Dr Jatto. I spend so much money on tickets just to make sure I win. But I never knew there was always something behind every lucky winner until the day I met Dr Jatto online, which I saw many people have talked about that he's very great when it comes to casting lottery spells, so I decided to give him a try. I contacted this great Dr Jatto and he did a spell and gave me the winning lottery numbers. But believe me when the draws came out I was among the lucky winners. I won 60 million dollars, with this great man you can win millions of dollars through the lottery. I am very happy to meet this great man. Dr Jatto Call :+234 901 616 2155 or Email: drjattolovespelltemple01@gmail. com

ashley ashleywalters 29 October 2024

My name is ashley walters !!! i am very grateful sharing this great testimonies with you all, The best thing that has ever happened in my life, is how I won the Powerball lottery. I do believe that someday i will win the Powerball lottery. Finally my dreams came through when i contacted Dr. OSE and tell him i needed the lottery winning special numbers cause i have come a long way spending money on ticket just to make sure i win. But i never knew that winning was so easy with the help of Dr. OSE, until the day i meant the spell caster testimony online, which a lot of people has talked about that he is very powerful and has great powers in casting lottery spell, so i decided to give it a try. I emailed Dr. OSE and he did a spell and gave me the winning lottery special numbers 62, and co-incidentally I have be playing this same number for the past 23years without any winning, But believe me when I play the special number 62 this time and the draws were out i was the mega winner because the special 62 matched all five white-ball numbers as well as the Powerball, in the April 4 drawing to win the $70 million jackpot prize...… Dr. OSE, truly you are the best, with Dr. OSE you can will millions of money through lottery. i am a living testimony and so very happy i meant him, and i will forever be grateful to him...… you can Email him for your own winning special lottery numbers now oseremenspelltemple @ gmail. com whatsapp +2348136482342

Grant Castillou 25 October 2024

It's becoming clear that with all the brain and consciousness theories out there, the proof will be in the pudding. By this I mean, can any particular theory be used to create a human adult level conscious machine. My bet is on the late Gerald Edelman's Extended Theory of Neuronal Group Selection. The lead group in robotics based on this theory is the Neurorobotics Lab at UC at Irvine. Dr. Edelman distinguished between primary consciousness, which came first in evolution, and that humans share with other conscious animals, and higher order consciousness, which came to only humans with the acquisition of language. A machine with only primary consciousness will probably have to come first.

What I find special about the TNGS is the Darwin series of automata created at the Neurosciences Institute by Dr. Edelman and his colleagues in the 1990's and 2000's. These machines perform in the real world, not in a restricted simulated world, and display convincing physical behavior indicative of higher psychological functions necessary for consciousness, such as perceptual categorization, memory, and learning. They are based on realistic models of the parts of the biological brain that the theory claims subserve these functions. The extended TNGS allows for the emergence of consciousness based only on further evolutionary development of the brain areas responsible for these functions, in a parsimonious way. No other research I've encountered is anywhere near as convincing.

I post because on almost every video and article about the brain and consciousness that I encounter, the attitude seems to be that we still know next to nothing about how the brain and consciousness work; that there's lots of data but no unifying theory. I believe the extended TNGS is that theory. My motivation is to keep that theory in front of the public. And obviously, I consider it the route to a truly conscious machine, primary and higher-order.

My advice to people who want to create a conscious machine is to seriously ground themselves in the extended TNGS and the Darwin automata first, and proceed from there, by applying to Jeff Krichmar's lab at UC Irvine, possibly. Dr. Edelman's roadmap to a conscious machine can be found at Jeff Krichmar's UCI website. IAI won't let me post a link.