AI seems to be hurtling us into a future that is, depending on your view, terrifying or thrilling. But for political scientist and big-data theorist Carl Öhman, AI is something else: the tyranny of the past over the present. By scraping our digital history and feeding it back to us, AI threatens to lock us into the demands of the past, leaving us unable to begin anew. Even if it achieves genuine innovation, Öhman argues, this will be an innovation controlled by the logic of the past. To resist, we must embrace the unpredictability of the present and the future—realms outside AI’s reach.
For both its critics and cheerleaders, AI is a harbinger of something new, a force that catapults us into the future with unprecedented speed. I say the opposite: AI, shiny as it may seem, is but the personified agency of the past reaching out into the present. The threat it poses is less an encroaching tyranny of the machine over humanity than a tyranny of the past over the present, a necrocratic order by which the dead reign over the living.
To see why this is, we only need to look at the raw material from which AI is built: data—the “new oil” of the world economy. While most commonly used to illustrate an economic shift, the metaphor also holds a deeper truth: that data is essentially our compressed past presented as a single substance. As the name “fossil fuel” indicates, real oil is composed of the remains of marine microorganisms—our long-dead ancestors—that, over millennia, accumulate on the seafloor.
Data is the fossil fuel of the digital economy, for it too is nothing but the accumulated remains of the past, the digital corpses of our former selves and ancestors, if you will. Whether in the form of social media posts, a company’s quarterly sales, or the records of an electric meter, data are the traces—not only a symbol, representation, or reflection—of some prior event. Our daily search history, scrolling, texting, browsing, and socializing are microorganisms that fall to the internet’s seafloor, where they will eventually be extracted to fuel the engines of prediction that propel the digital economy.
___
The challenge posed by AI is not so much to save humanity from the machines—the machines are us—but to save the present from the combined force of our past.
___
Just like oil, data are the fossilized past, compressed into a single substance. They are literally the corpus upon which AI systems are trained. So, when we say that AI emerges from data, what we are really saying is that it emerges from the past; just as a pancake is composed of milk, flour and eggs, the agency of AI is essentially composed of corpora scraped from the web—it is those digital remains, presented in a new format. Victor Frankenstein built his monster from a composite of human corpses; we build ours from the digital corpses that have accumulated on the internet’s seafloor.
When thus construed, the challenge posed by AI is not so much to save humanity from the machines—the machines are us—but to save the present from the combined force of our past.
SUGGESTED VIEWING The future of the AI economy With Martin Wolf, Sebastian Mallaby
Want to continue reading?
Get unlimited access to insights from the world's leading thinkers.
Browse our subscription plans and subscribe to read more.
Already a subscriber? Log in
Join the conversation