For hundreds of years, we've been told that science and ethics are fundamentally separate - that the scientific method cannot tells us how we ought to live and that morality has no bearing on scientific facts. But New York philosopher James Liszka, leading authority on Charles Peirce's ethics, argues this is a mistake. Unearthing the work of America's greatest forgotten polymath, he argues that a deeper understanding of the scientific method reveals how a pragmatic, experimentalist approach can resolve our ethical problems too.
After many years of work on the logic of science, Charles Sanders Peirce realized that it needed an ethical grounding. The founder of pragmatism wrote a letter in 1902 to William James, his longtime friend and compatriot, confessing how “stupid” he was in failing to recognize this. In his last, unpublished work on logic, he wrote that he had “spared no elbow-grease” in polishing its “lens” with the ingredient of ethics, “showing much that was not discernible before.” What Peirce saw was a rather novel approach to ethics. Instead of relying on ethical principles, Peirce argues for a process by which ethical problems can be sorted out. Scientific inquiry itself can serve as the model for that process. But to understand this, we first have to understand his work on the logic of science.
Pragmatism and the scientific method
Peirce certainly had scientific street credentials. He did his graduate work in experimental chemistry at the innovative Lawrence Scientific School at Harvard. He was well-trained in mathematics, his father being the greatest American mathematician of the time. After graduation, he worked at the Harvard Observatory, making precise measurements of the brightness of stars in order to better map the Milky Way. This was complemented by his work with the US Geodetic Survey to measure the shape of the Earth more precisely. But he claimed he had been a student of logic from the age of 12.
In 1877, Peirce presented his logic of science in a series of articles for The Popular Science Monthly, entitled “Illustrations on the Logic of Science.” They formed the basis of a philosophy that came to be known as pragmatism.
Peirce argued that scientific method, broadly understood, provides epistemic reliability. It is the best way to assuage doubt, settle opinion and fix beliefs. And, ultimately, he came to realize that the same method could settle our ethical beliefs too. This is due to three features of scientific practice.
___
Science is reliable because it is a very sophisticated version of trial and error.
___
First, experimental science rests implicitly on metaphysical realism. Regardless of what inquirers believe, there exists an order to things independent of those beliefs. When those beliefs are tested in the right way, the order of the world will decide whether those beliefs are in error or not.
Second, experimental design is a very good model for clarifying our concepts and beliefs, all the better to test them. By understanding what something does under certain conditions—how it functions—that provides a more specific way of understanding what it means. Yes, a concept such as ‘hardness’ could be subjectively assessed through touch. But by using the Mohs test, for example, hardness can be objectively measured. The test is to settle which minerals scratch or are scratched by others, defining their rank order of hardness. Proceeding in this way, we would discover that diamonds are the hardest mineral, even if we thought iron was. This idea became the basis of what is called the pragmatic maxim.
Want to continue reading?
Get unlimited access to insights from the world's leading thinkers.
Browse our subscription plans and subscribe to read more.
Already a subscriber? Log in
Join the conversation