Beyond the limits of reason

An interview with Simon Critchley

In this interview, I sit down with Simon Critchley, Hans Jonas Professor of Philosophy at The New School for Social Research in New York, to explore his provocative new book, On Mysticism. Drawing on medieval Christian figures like Julian of Norwich and Marguerite Porete, Critchley argues that ecstatic experience, intense love, and a willingness to be “outside oneself” can offer a counterbalance to the narrowly rational outlook dominant in modern philosophy. Throughout our conversation, he probes the boundaries of faith and reason, discuss the possibility of maintaining mysticism alongside science, and question the role of philosophy itself in shaping our cultural consciousness. What follows is only a short, edited extract from Critchley’s call for more openness, both in our thinking and our collective search for meaning. Link to the full interview.

 

Omari Edwards: You begin your book by contrasting Hamlet’s melancholic skepticism with the promise of mysticism. How would you define mysticism, and why did you choose Hamlet as the starting point for exploring it?

___

I see Hamlet as the quintessential philosopher, melancholic, who is the cleverest person we could imagine. And he's sad, he's depressed.

___

Simon Critchley: Mysticism is experience in its most intense form, experience in its most intense form. So what mysticism is about, who these mystics were, were people that were able to experience an intensity of aliveness and and love and a sense of being outside themselves, ecstasy. So, the subtitle of the book in in the UK is the experience of ecstasy. That sense of being outside oneself is really what I'm trying to say. That's the core of mystical experience. And we can, we can get there by pushing ourselves out of the way as much as possible.

I see Hamlet as the quintessential philosopher, melancholic, who is the cleverest person we could imagine. And he's sad, he's depressed, and his extraordinary intelligence leads to a melancholy. It leads, in his case, to the extinction of the capacity to love. I see that melancholy, rational, skeptical disposition all over the place in philosophy. And so mysticism poses a significant challenge to that and a different way of opening things up.

Analytic philosophy is often seen as radically opposed to mysticism and even its opposite. Do you think analytic philosophy is fundamentally flawed?

The modern idea of philosophy as a critical, rational and naturalistic practice... focus[es] very much on questions of its relationship to science, a kind of under laborer to science, as John Locke described it.

___

Philosophers are quite awful people most of the time.

___

Philosophy is now just a critical enterprise which I think at the edges flaps into a cynicism. It’s usually impossible to persuade philosophers of anything, in my experience and I’ve been doing this for 35 years, teaching—philosophers are quite awful people most of the time...

The promise of philosophy was not just analytical rigor. It was a kind of manic, divine love. That’s what you find in you know, in Plato’s Phaedrus, in the Symposium, and even in boring old Aristotle... a contemplative life would be the life of the gods.

 

What do you mean by saying that philosophers should cultivate openness?

I find that the modern idea of philosophy leads to an incredibly narrow understanding of philosophy. We end up misrecognizing the history of philosophy and imposing our current mode onto the historical accounts. So, the least we can do is trying to open our minds a little bit.

___

Philosophy has to be part of culture. Philosophy isn’t something that takes place in a handful of academic departments.

___

Continue reading

Enjoy unlimited access to the world's leading thinkers.

Start by exploring our subscription options or joining our mailing list today.

Start Free Trial

Already a subscriber? Log in

Latest Releases
Join the conversation

grace landon 7 April 2025

I was so lucky to win the $1 million prize in the lottery. I have been playing the powerball lottery for about 20 years, and i didn't win any big amount until Dr. Lucas helped me with his spiritual winning numbers, I thought it was all fake until he gave me the numbers and directed me on how to play. He gave me assurance that I was going to win and asked me to give him 48 hours to finish his work, which I did. The third day, he gave me the numbers and gave me instructions on how to play, and luckily, I won. I want to let everyone who is reading this to know that this spell really works and you can also be a winner if you give it a try to see for yourself. The moment you contact Dr Lucas for help is the end of suffering in your life, he has been helping people around the world and I'm happy that I'm among those who has benefited from his great work he's doing, you can reach him if you really want to win the lottery Email: Drlucasspelltemple@gmail. com Or WhatsApp +234 904 794 3567 Thank You

Mike Grusso 1 6 April 2025

HOW I WAS ABLE TO RETRIEVE MY LOST BTC AND USDT WITH THE HELP OF THE HACK ANGELS


Getting back your stolen bitcoins is very easy but there are also lots of fraudulent recovery firms out there so one needs to be careful not to end up being defrauded again. When my world seemed to crumble after losing a significant amount of Bitcoin. I was devastated. I came across numerous testimonials about THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY COMPANY, a crypto recovery and cyber security company. I sent him a direct message Contact inform:

WhatsApp +1(520)200-2320 )

He listened to my concerns to which he replied and requested some information, which I also provided. To my surprise, I was able to reclaim what I thought was lost forever. I am forever grateful for the exceptional service provided by THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY COMPANY

Marcus Ruiz 25 March 2025

Since I was a child, I've envisioned owning an electric truck, but I never imagined my dream would become a reality. Currently, I possess a Cybertruck from Tesla, a feat made possible by Lord Meduza, the spell caster who created a lottery spell that secured my MEGA MILLION winning ticket of $156,000,000 million dollars. Currently, my family and I are completely debt-free and we enjoy life like celebrities, haha. Allow Lord Meduza to revive your forgotten dreams in 48 hours, as this is the sole method to succeed in winning the lottery. His fortunate numbers are not anticipated but fated for greatness. His spells include various types, such as healing from illnesses or ailments, seeking employment, or attempting to rekindle a relationship with an ex. Simply get in touch with him via the below details and God Bless..
Email: Lordmeduzatemple@hotmail.
com
Whats-App: +18079072687.

quatisha brown 14 January 2025

I just want the whole world to know about this spell caster I met two weeks ago,I cannot say everything he has done for me and my family I was going through online when I meant this wonderful man's testimony online how he won a lottery through the help of dr Ose I decided to just give it a try and my life is back to me now after i lost my job due to covid  he gave me a winning numbers to play lottery and i won 5000usd for my first play since then i have been working with him and he has been giving me numbers to play my lottery i can not write everything he has done for me if you need a lottery spell today contact him on oseremenspelltemple @ gmail. com