IQ tests are back and as dangerous as ever

iq tests are back and as dangerous as ever3

To understand our minds, we often turn to science. We learn that love is an oxytocin surge, that IQ tests measure intelligence, that certain behaviours signal ADHD. But, argues philosopher of psychology Devin Sanchez Curry, this promise of definitive descriptions of the mind is a dangerous illusion. The mind is a moving target, influenced by how we describe it: people behave differently if they see love as a chemical reaction rather than a social commitment, or intelligence as a test score rather than a cluster of traits, impossible to boil down to a single measure. In a world where Trump has popularized the insult “low-IQ,” we must not passively allow our classifications to shape our minds; rather we must use them to shape who we want to be.

 

Gilbert Ryle, the greatest list writer in the history of philosophy, began his influential discussion of intelligence by naming “a few” of its varieties: the intelligent person is “‘clever’, ‘sensible’, ‘careful’, ‘methodical’, ‘inventive’, ‘prudent’, ‘acute’, ‘logical’, ‘witty’, ‘observant’, ‘critical’, ‘experimental’, ‘quick-witted’, ‘cunning’, ‘wise’, ‘judicious’, [or] ‘scrupulous’”; the stupid person, by contrast, is “‘dull’, ‘silly’, ‘careless’, ‘unmethodical’, ‘uninventive’, ‘rash’, ‘dense’, ‘illogical’, ‘humourless’, ‘unobservant’, ‘uncritical’, ‘unexperimental’, ‘slow’, ‘simple’, ‘unwise’, [or] ‘injudicious’.” The differences between these adjectives matter. You should tell jokes to your quick-witted cousin that you don’t tell to your slow cousin, and you should tell jokes to your slow cousin that you don’t tell to your humourless cousin. Moreover, being intelligent in some ways doesn’t preclude people from being stupid in others: your humourless and dense uncle might nevertheless be sensible, and your quick-witted aunt might nevertheless be unobservant and injudicious.

These lists show that while “stupid” and “intelligent” can be perfectly accurate ways of describing people, they are rarely the best way. There’s always a more precise word you could choose that would describe somebody in more detail, and that would provide more useful information for the purposes of interacting with them or understanding their character.

___

IQ tests fail to track most of the qualities that Ryle recognized as varieties of intelligence.

___

Nevertheless, an unearned power seems to attach to the use of umbrella words like “intelligent” and “stupid” in practice. If a politician credibly describes themselves or their ally as intelligent, rather than picking a more precise compliment, they convey to the voting public that they are somehow generally intelligent: that they are clever, sensible, careful, methodical, inventive, prudent, acute, logical, witty, observant, critical, experimental, quick-witted, cunning, wise, judicious and scrupulous. If a politician describes someone as stupid, or “dumb as a rock,” rather than picking a more precise insult, they insinuate that the whole list of stupidity-adjectives applies to that person. However, what complimenters and insulters gain in scope from the use of vague umbrella words, they lose in incisiveness. If only there were a way to insinuate that one’s adversary is utterly devoid of intelligence without forgoing the cutting specificity of the more precise adjectives.

Ah but there is! The President of the United States’ go-to move of calling people “low IQ” serves to signal that his (disproportionately Black) targets are generally unintelligent. At the same time, “low IQ individual” comes off as more precise than Trump’s other preferred insult, “dumb as a rock.” IQ is a specific, measurable trait: not merely precise but scientific. Other racists have long been preoccupied with IQ (and in some cases occupied as IQ researchers) for the same reason. It allows them to put on airs of scientific precision when they dismiss whole groups of people as generally and thoroughly daft.

***

 

Want to continue reading?

Get unlimited access to insights from the world's leading thinkers.

Browse our subscription plans and subscribe to read more.

Start Free Trial

Already a subscriber? Log in

Latest Releases
Join the conversation