Physicalism, consciousness, Hard problem of consciousness, Philosophy of mind, Emergent substance dualism, Mind-body problem

The world is not made of one thing, but two

Mind is irreducible to matter

world two things

Dividing mind from matter has dominated Western thought since Descartes. But more recently the idea that everything is fundamentally physcial has taken hold. Here, philosopher William Hasker, in conversation with social scientist Tony Sobrado, explores the failures of physicalism and argues that mind is irreducible to matter. 

 

 

Tony Sobrado: Perhaps the most important question in philosophy of mind, and even in neuroscience and cognitive science, is whether consciousness can be fully explained solely in physical terms and thus by the physical brain alone. Physicalism is loosely the idea that everything that exists and can ever possibly exist in the universe, and thus also consciousness, is ultimately physical. Physicalism, albeit notoriously difficult to define, is a philosophical position that permeates the contemporary world and is implicitly assumed across both the social and natural sciences, and even often in philosophy of mind. Long gone are the days of Descartes’ substance dualism; today, few philosophers are even property dualists. Yet our mental goings-on, our inner world, and our subjective experience still pose significant challenges across many fields of study.

When we talk of reductionism and reducing consciousness to the physical brain, there are multifaceted forms of reduction, including theoretical reduction, explanatory reduction, conceptual reduction and ontological reduction. As a pre-eminent philosopher and theologian who endorses dualism, why do you think consciousness cannot be reduced to, and thus completely explained by, the physical brain?

___

Consciousness is not merely another physical property among all those other physical properties. Consciousness is experience itself.

___ 

William Hasker: The starting point here is what David Chalmers famously called the hard problem of consciousness. We have descriptions of brain processes, neural activity, information processing, and so forth (the easy problem), but nobody has a genuine explanation of how consciousness itself arises from those physical brain processes (the hard problem). What strikes me is that there is simply no clear place to begin. We know what physical explanations look like because physics describes relations, structures, forces, and causal processes of physical properties only. Yet consciousness is not merely another physical property among all those other physical properties. Consciousness is experience itself. That is why I have always found reductionist accounts unsatisfactory.

It is not that they fail to answer a particular technical question, but rather they fail to provide any convincing account of why subjective experience should emerge from physical processes in the first place. A physical law cannot be conscious, and physical properties and physical laws say nothing about conscious experience, so it is difficult to see how physicalism can completely account for conscious experience.  

Tony Sobrado: The issue regarding physical laws, specifically, and conscious experience is paramount. The intrinsically objective independent nature of physical laws cannot be accompanied by any mental or subjective features. My essay here at IAI News, titled Panpsychism does not solve the hard problem of consciousness, argues how any mental features capable of non-linear and non-deterministic properties cannot be coupled with physical laws because it would fail to guarantee the objectivity of physical laws in the first place. This is because subjective experience is an open-ended domain, failing to possess uniformly determined parameters by virtue of being an experience that is subjective and individualised, as opposed to being monolithic and invariable like physical laws. This objectivity problem of panpsychism illustrates the general problem faced when attempting to marry objective physical laws and subjective experience that result from basic physicalism. 

consciousness is the hidden architecture SUGGESTED READING Consciousness is the hidden architecture behind fundamental and quantum physics By Harald A. Wiltsche

Want to continue reading?

Get unlimited access to insights from the world's leading thinkers.

Browse our subscription plans and subscribe to read more.

Start Free Trial

Already a subscriber? Log in

Latest Releases
Join the conversation