The prospect of immortality has been with humanity for as long as we have understood our own mortality. It has been explored in culture after culture through mysticism, religion and, latterly, medical technology. The prospect of immortality is a uniquely human optimism created in answer to a uniquely human curse – the ability to contemplate our own existence, and its inevitable end.

As our technology improves, the prospect of immortality is beginning to look less and less ludicrous. Perhaps not true immortality any time soon, but the idea that in the mid-to-distant future we might be able to prevent ageing and eradicate most diseases is at least conceivable. But before we allow ourselves to become hopeful, it is important to give serious philosophical thought to the pros and cons of living indefinitely. Are there any convincing objections to the prospect of immortality?

The most common dismissal of the desirability of individual immortality is the point that it would not be worth living only to watch all of our friends and loved ones grow old and die. This is a valid criticism, but not a strong one. After all, the longest-living person in any group is already going to go through this, without any of the added benefits of perpetual youth and with many fewer opportunities to make new friends and find new lovers. Yet we would not give nearly so much credence to the argument that we should not prolong the lives of the elderly so as to save them the pain of watching their friends die.